A building contractor, Ben Matthews, comes to the M&B Hardware store to talk about a contract for the store to supply plumbing fixtures. The contractor (Peter Graves) turns out to be Lucy's first love, "Goofy", from their Highschool days when they first met during a dance, called the "Big Apple". Now he wants to rekindle the flame, but Lucy feels otherwise.
Episode Video:
Special Notes: This is actually the only time on Life with Lucy that Lucille is not wearing slacks, a bathrobe, or a housecoat.